Skip to content
The Wire
STATKawhi So Serious? leads at 4–0TRADEHeHateMe comes away with Jrue Holiday, Jabari Smith Jr. · Kawhi So Serious? walks off with Stephen Curry, Brice Sensabaugh, 2028 R3WIREWemby and friends grabs Keegan MurrayWIREShep and Co. adds Quentin GrimesWIREHeHateMe scoops up Mo BambaWIREHeHateMe grabs Oso IghodaroWIREWemby and friends plucks Kevin HuerterWIREP. Giddey brings in Sandro MamukelashviliWIREHeHateMe cuts Ryan KalkbrennerWIRESam Presti’s Burner grabs Tyrese ProctorTHE NUMBER16-5: brodiedean8's 2024 regular season, the second-best record in league history.STATWeek 4 Hardware · High Score: P. Giddey (364.75) · Bad Beat: Shep and Co. (332.25)PODThe Association Podcast, Ep. 5: Kawhi So Serious About 2029?NEWRebuild Index: Only Matticus Gets Paid for LosingNEWRebuild Index: One Real Rebuild in the Bottom FourNEWHot Seat: Brodie Keeps Losing Games He Left on the BenchNEWRebuild Index: The Dybantsa Pick Is Why BigSuge Is StuckNEWContender Test: Colt's Title Case Lives on the Bench
Rebuild IndexWeek 5, 2026

Rebuild Index: Only Matticus Gets Paid for Losing

Ryen RussilloffNovember 19, 20266 min read

The bottom four of Da League are a combined 3-13, and the standings page treats them like one big tank. Before you buy that, check who owns their 2027 firsts. brodiedean8's pick belongs to BigSuge. BigSuge's pick belongs to lilsweet96. Nighthawk2334's pick has belonged to matticus808 since this month. Of the four franchises sitting at 1-3 or worse, matticus808 is the only one whose losses land in his own draft column.

That changes how you grade the other three. A losing team without its own pick gets nothing from the losses except a worse mood, so the only question worth asking about brodiedean8, Nighthawk2334 and BigSuge is whether they have a plan to win their way out. Two of them don't.

brodiedean8 (HeHateMe), 1-3. Grade: C-

The record says rebuild, and the ledger closed that option a long time ago. HeHateMe owns zero future firsts and ranks 10th of 10 in pick value. The 2027 first sits with BigSuge, the 2028 first with Natebarrett5, and the 2029 first went to goochshot in July in the deal that returned Julius Randle and Isaiah Collier. If brodiedean8 tanked for three straight seasons, he would hand three different franchises a better pick and collect nothing himself.

He also doesn't need to. HeHateMe has scored 1268.75 points, more than Natebarrett5's 2-2 team has scored. The Rebuild Lab projects his window at 111 next season, second only to the champion's 112. This is a contender with a bad month of luck and a lineup problem, and brodiedean8 diagnosed the second part himself in chat: "Cade 73 ball on the pine." Lineup decisions are the cheapest problem in this league to fix.

The November trade with 44Colt points the right direction. brodiedean8 sent Stephen Curry, Brice Sensabaugh and his own 2028 third and got back Jrue Holiday, Jabari Smith Jr. and Anthony Black. Holiday is the same guard he sent to Colt in June inside the Trae Young package, and he is back in the HeHateMe starting lineup five months later, with Black starting next to him. A team whose only executable plan is winning should turn bench pieces into starters, and that is what this did.

The trouble is the third-rounder in that deal. brodiedean8 bought that pick back in August by sending Meleek Thomas to matticus808, and Thomas is now a part-time starter in Cleveland averaging 13.6 points and 2.6 threes across 11 games as of November 17. A young guard with a real role became a third-round pick, and the third-round pick became a sweetener for a veteran he used to own. That is how a contender with no firsts slowly runs out of things to trade. Add the seven second- and third-rounders he drafted this summer, Cameron Carr already flipped to matticus808 for Yves Missi, and you have a GM spending a rebuilder's energy on a roster built to win around Nikola Jokić.

Timeline: this season and next. What to do: set the lineup, keep buying with players, and stop leaking the young assets that are the only currency he has left.

Who should care, and what changes next?

Nighthawk2334 (Shane Gillis Alexander), 1-3. Grade: D-

The roster projects at 105 and has scored at 99, and the gap between those two numbers is the injury report. Jaren Jackson Jr. has been out with a knee injury since late October, Jalen Duren is out with a hamstring, Lauri Markkanen is out with his hand, and Austin Reaves went out with a heel as of today. Meanwhile Tyler Herro has hit 20 points in four of his last five games, and Fred VanVleet had 56 assists against 11 turnovers in his 10 games since returning. If you believe the healthy version of this team is above average, your own first projects late, and trading it for help looks cheap.

Tank Watch already counted what Nighthawk's losses now do for matticus808. The newer problem is the timing of the sale. Nighthawk2334 sent their own 2027 first to matticus808 for Rui Hachimura and 44Colt's 2027 second, and they did it with four rotation players hurt, which is the exact week the market prices their pick highest. Try defending that to ownership: we sold our first at its peak value for a rotation forward and a second-rounder from the only unbeaten team, which means the second lands near the bottom of its round. Nobody in that room is nodding.

He still holds his 2028 and 2029 firsts and drafted Keaton Wagler at No. 6 in this summer's rookie draft, so the cupboard is not bare. But the Lab has his roster at 98 for each of the next two seasons. Timeline: none that I can see. What to do: with the 2027 pick gone, every loss is a gift to matticus808, so the only sane path is to get healthy and win as many games this season as the roster allows.

BigSuge (Flat Earth Advocates), 1-3. Grade: D

Flat Earth Advocates has scored 1014.75, second-worst in the league, with the second-oldest starting group at a weighted 28.8. The big names are fine. Jayson Tatum scored 32 and 34 in back-to-back wins as of November 17, and LaMelo Ball dropped a season-high 34 against Milwaukee. The number that cools all of that is Draymond Green, who holds a starting spot while averaging 3.2 points a game, a career low, as of November 18. Ja Morant is out with a hamstring injury. The stars are producing and the roster around them is not.

The June trade explains why losing does BigSuge no good. He sent Nickeil Alexander-Walker, Matas Buzelis, brodiedean8's 2026 first, brodiedean8's 2026 second and his own 2027 first to lilsweet96 for Kyrie Irving and Darius Garland. Alexander-Walker and Buzelis both start for Wemby and friends, brodiedean8's 2026 first became Nate Ament, and lilsweet96 still holds BigSuge's 2027 first. Every BigSuge loss improves a contender's draft stock.

His best rebuild asset is brodiedean8's 2027 first, and the Lab projects HeHateMe as the second-best team next season. BigSuge's rebuild is pinned to a pick from a team that should climb. What to do: sell veterans for a first he can actually root for. avery228 still owns his own 2027 first. The one buyer BigSuge should avoid is lilsweet96, because every veteran he sends there makes his own team worse and lilsweet96's copy of his pick better. Timeline: 2028 at the earliest, and only if he stops standing still. The Lab has him quiet for 60 days.

The Paradox: Natebarrett5 Is the Buyer BigSuge Needs

Coopa Troopas is 2-2 with a rebuilder's balance sheet: six future firsts, second in pick value, the youngest starters in the league at a weighted 24.1, and a roster the Lab projects to 110 by 2028-29. Natebarrett5 has no business selling anything for picks. He beat matticus808 345.75-212.25 in Week 4 and sits at 68% to make the playoffs.

The useful wrinkle is which firsts he holds. Natebarrett5 owns 44Colt's 2028 first, attached to the oldest contending core in the league and a roster the Lab has falling to 97 by 2028-29. That is the exact pick BigSuge should be asking for, and Natebarrett5 is the GM with both the motive to buy a veteran and the spare capital to pay for one.

matticus808 (Sam Presti's Burner), 0-4. Grade: A-

Sam Presti's Burner has scored 830.25 points, 184.50 behind the ninth-place team. That is a real tank, and matticus808 is the only GM in the bottom four who owns his 2027, 2028 and 2029 firsts outright. Then look at what he did this fall. In August he sent Jaden McDaniels to Natebarrett5 for Jared McCain and Natebarrett5's 2027 third. In November he packaged that third with Anfernee Simons for 44Colt's 2027 second, then sent that second and Rui Hachimura to Nighthawk2334 for Nighthawk's 2027 first. Three veterans became Jared McCain and a first from a team stuck at 1-3. That is the cleanest asset chain anyone in this league has run this season.

The hole is the Lab's own projection: 74 this season, 81 next, 88 in 2028-29, still below average two years out. That projection counts the players he already rosters. Seven future firsts aren't players yet, and three of his best ones have been hurt for most of the year: Jalen Williams out with a leg injury since October 28, Chet Holmgren out with a knee since October 31, Cason Wallace out with a shoulder. Ajay Mitchell is averaging career highs, 21.1 points a game when he starts, as of November 18, and the Meleek Thomas pickup cost a single third-rounder. Nobody can tell you where those seven firsts will land. I can tell you nobody else in the bottom four has a plan I would sign off on.

Strip it down and the upside case comes to one pick. Beyond his own three firsts and the goochshot and Nighthawk 2027s, matticus808 holds 44Colt's 2029 first. The Lab calls Colt's roster the oldest contending core in the league, projects it sliding to 97 by 2028-29, and lists zero future firsts in Colt's drawer to restock it. That pick conveys off the season the decline is supposed to show up.

44Colt is 4-0 and buying, and every veteran he adds this season is a down payment on matticus808's 2029 draft.

Reported from 4 approved sources in the league record.

R

Ryen Russilloff

Lead Analyst

Roster construction, contender/rebuild analysis, structural deep dives

What this is built on

Source records logged for this story:

  • SleeperCurrent standings
  • LoreFranchise lore
  • ArticleRecent related coverage
  • SleeperLeague database (Sleeper sync)

See something wrong?

Every claim here is grounded in real data. If we got one wrong, tell us.