Skip to content
The Wire
STATKawhi So Serious? leads at 4–0TRADEHeHateMe comes away with Jrue Holiday, Jabari Smith Jr. · Kawhi So Serious? walks off with Stephen Curry, Brice Sensabaugh, 2028 R3WIREWemby and friends grabs Keegan MurrayWIREShep and Co. adds Quentin GrimesWIREHeHateMe scoops up Mo BambaWIREHeHateMe grabs Oso IghodaroWIREWemby and friends plucks Kevin HuerterWIREP. Giddey brings in Sandro MamukelashviliWIREHeHateMe cuts Ryan KalkbrennerWIRESam Presti’s Burner grabs Tyrese ProctorTHE NUMBER67 points: Luka Dončić for alecb5 in Week 3, 2026, the third-highest starter score in league history.STATWeek 4 Hardware · High Score: P. Giddey (364.75) · Bad Beat: Shep and Co. (332.25)PODThe Association Podcast, Ep. 5: Kawhi So Serious About 2029?NEWRebuild Index: One Real Rebuild in the Bottom FourNEWRebuild Index: The Dybantsa Pick Is Why BigSuge Is StuckNEWContender Test: Colt's Title Case Lives on the BenchNEWRebuild Index: Matticus Owns the Picks, Nate Owns the TimelineNEWWeek 3 Recap: Wemby's Night Covered for the Worse Team
Rebuild IndexWeek 4, 2026

Rebuild Index: Matticus Owns the Picks, Nate Owns the Timeline

Ryen RussilloffNovember 16, 20266 min read

The consensus says matticus808 is running the only real rebuild in Da League, and the 0-3 start is supposed to prove it. Half of that holds up. I went back through the deal ledger for the four franchises the Rebuild Lab places outside the contending tiers: Sam Presti's Burner, Coopa Troopas, Shane Gillis Alexander and Flat Earth Advocates. The best rebuild in this league belongs to a GM nobody describes as rebuilding.

Losing games earns nothing on this list. A plan a GM could walk into the room and defend to ownership earns the grade.

Sam Presti's Burner (matticus808): A-

Record: 0-3, 618.00 points. Window index: 68 this season, first in the league in pick value with seven future firsts.

This is the deepest audit because it is the most instructive one. matticus808 drafted Tyrese Haliburton, Walker Kessler and Trey Murphy III in the dispersal draft and turned all three into futures within weeks. Murphy went to goochshot for goochshot's 2026 and 2027 firsts; the 2026 pick became Morez Johnson at No. 9 in the rookie draft, and the 2027 pick is still live. Jeremiah Fears, Ace Bailey and matticus808's own 2026 first went to lilsweet96, and that return became Darryn Peterson at No. 2 and Kingston Flemings at No. 7. Haliburton and Kessler went to alecb5 for Tyler Herro, Chet Holmgren and alecb5's 2028 first, and Herro moved again to Nighthawk2334 for Tre Johnson and a second that became Labaron Philon.

Then the fall work. Miles Bridges and Nic Claxton went to 44Colt for 44Colt's 2029 first plus seconds, and Rui Hachimura went to Nighthawk2334 for Nighthawk's 2027 first. The 2029 pick is the one I'd frame. The Lab calls 44Colt's roster the oldest contending core in the league, with starters at a weighted age of 30.2 and a projection that slides from 105 to 97 by 2028-29. matticus808 bought a pick from the team most likely to be paying for its title run in three years, and paid for it with two veterans they had no use for.

The process is clean and the losing is intentional; my problem is with what the process has built. Count the point guards on this roster: Ajay Mitchell, Peterson, Flemings, Philon, Nikola Topić, Cameron Carr, Kasparas Jakučionis and Jase Richardson. That is eight. The healthy frontcourt is Isaiah Hartenstein and a rookie in Morez Johnson, because Holmgren (knee, as of 10-31), Thomas Sorber (knee, as of 11-13) and Jaylin Williams (back, as of 11-15) are all out.

The injury report is the other half of the 618.00. Jalen Williams, Holmgren, Cason Wallace, Tre Johnson, Sorber, Flemings, Jaylin Williams and De'Andre Hunter are all listed out as of mid-November, and Tre Johnson and Hunter are sitting in the starting lineup anyway. That is a lineup-management leak a tanking team can afford, though the 160.25 in the Week 1 loss to BigSuge tells you how bad it gets when nobody cleans it up.

There is real upside on the floor. Peterson scored a career-high 28 on November 14. Meleek Thomas, acquired from brodiedean8 for a 2028 third, is shooting 47.3% from three across 10 games as of 11-15, which is about as good as a third-round price gets. Jared McCain, acquired from Natebarrett5 for Jaden McDaniels, reportedly has a good chance to stay a starter because Wallace and Jalen Williams are hurt. Both of those players sit on matticus808's own injured list, so the roster is opening minutes for itself.

The eye test on Peterson runs hot, and the number that cools it is the Lab's roster projection: 74, then 79, then 84 by 2028-29. Even three seasons out, the players already rostered grade well below a league-average team. Every bit of the gap has to come from picks hitting and from a trade this GM hasn't made yet.

What it forces: a consolidation deal, two or three of those guards for one real big. Timeline: 2028-29 is the earliest credible push, and only if two of Peterson, Flemings and Morez Johnson become fantasy starters. The plan is real. The minus is for a roster shape that will cost matticus808 value when they try to sell guards into a league that already knows they have eight.

Who should care, and what changes next?

Coopa Troopas (Natebarrett5): A

Record: 1-2, 922.25 points. Window index: 102, 53% to make the playoffs, six future firsts, second in pick value.

Natebarrett5 ran the same playbook as matticus808 and kept a competitive team while doing it. In February, Nate sent Kawhi Leonard and Kristaps Porziņģis to 44Colt for Kyshawn George, 44Colt's 2027 and 2028 firsts, and brodiedean8's 2028 first. In June, Nate sent Ja Morant and Jalen Green to BigSuge for BigSuge's 2026 first and two seconds, and that first became AJ Dybantsa at No. 3. Nate also drafted Darius Acuff Jr. at No. 5, and Acuff is already starting next to Cooper Flagg, Dylan Harper and Cedric Coward.

The Lab has this roster at the league's youngest starting age, 23.8, and it is the only one in this audit projecting up every year: 100, then 106, then 112 by 2028-29. Coopa Troopas lost to the unbeaten goochshot by 336.25-328.00 in Week 3 and beat brodiedean8 by 348.25-280.50 in Week 2. A rebuilding team does not usually take the first-place team to the wire.

This is the paradox case in the other direction. Natebarrett5 should not lose a single game on purpose, because Nate's best future picks belong to other people. 44Colt is the league's Last Dance roster and brodiedean8 is All In with zero future firsts and the league's worst pick value. Every win-now move those two make raises the price of the picks sitting in Nate's account.

Timeline: now, with 2028 as the peak. What's missing: a frontcourt answer while Joel Embiid sits on injured reserve. That is a small hole on a roster built this well.

Shane Gillis Alexander (Nighthawk2334): C-

Record: 1-2, 925.25 points. Window index: 102, 54% to make the playoffs, seventh in pick value.

Nighthawk2334 sent the 2027 first to matticus808, and the return tells the story. Rui Hachimura is on the bench. The June deal for Herro and Neemias Queta at least produced two starters, at the cost of Tre Johnson and a second that became Labaron Philon, but the November deal produced a reserve.

The Lab projects this roster at 105, 104 and 102 over three seasons and labels it Peaking. The results say 102 so far, and the 375.75-272.50 loss to avery228 in Week 2 matters more than the 368.75-312.75 win over brodiedean8 in Week 3. With the 2027 first gone, a tank has no payoff, so the only executable plan is to win now.

The tool for that is already on the bench: Fred VanVleet, Jakob Poeltl, Lauri Markkanen, Austin Reaves, Coby White, Wendell Carter Jr., Tari Eason and Kel'el Ware. Two or three of those names for one star is the trade this roster demands. Keaton Wagler, the No. 6 pick, stays on the taxi squad and out of any deal. Timeline: this season or a reset. I'm not laying a C on a GM who sold the pick that made a reset possible.

Flat Earth Advocates (BigSuge): D

Record: 1-2, 756.00 points. Window index: 84, with starters at a weighted age of 28.8, the oldest of the four teams in this audit.

Follow BigSuge's own picks and the grade writes itself. The 2026 first went to Natebarrett5 with two seconds for Morant and Jalen Green, and it became AJ Dybantsa. The 2027 first went to lilsweet96 with Nickeil Alexander-Walker, Matas Buzelis and two brodiedean8 picks for Kyrie Irving and Darius Garland. As of mid-November, Morant (hamstring) and Irving (knee) are both out. BigSuge traded two firsts for two guards who aren't playing.

The working parts are real. Jayson Tatum is averaging 27.9 points, 6.2 rebounds and 8.0 assists as of 11-13, and Garland is at 20.9 points and 6.6 assists through eight games. Aday Mara, drafted at No. 8 with the alecb5 first BigSuge bought by sending Bennedict Mathurin to lilsweet96, is the lone young piece. brodiedean8's 2027 first is the best asset in the building.

The Lab projects this roster at 97 by 2028-29, below average and falling. That is the worst place in a dynasty: too old to wait and too weak to win. Tatum is the one asset that brings back a contender's future, so put him on the market while a team like 44Colt or alecb5 still has a reason to pay. Timeline: none until the veterans move.

The Paradox Ledger

Nighthawk2334 is the team that can't tank and won't consolidate. Natebarrett5 is the rebuild that should keep competing, and it is. matticus808 is the only franchise here losing for a reason, and BigSuge is losing without one.

The Upside Pick

So I'll put my name on it. matticus808 holds more lottery tickets than anyone in Da League, and that roster still projects at 84 three seasons out. Natebarrett5 holds the second-best pick stack, a starting five that already plays the unbeaten team to a single-digit finish, and the future firsts of the two franchises most likely to age out first.

The best rebuild in this league is the one that never needed a losing season to work.

Reported from 4 approved sources in the league record.

R

Ryen Russilloff

Lead Analyst

Roster construction, contender/rebuild analysis, structural deep dives

What this is built on

Every claim here is grounded in real league data. The receipts:

  • SleeperCurrent standings
  • LoreFranchise lore
  • ArticleRecent related coverage
  • SleeperLeague database (Sleeper sync)

See something wrong?

Every claim here is grounded in real data. If we got one wrong, tell us.