Skip to content
The Wire
STATKawhi So Serious? leads at 4–0TRADEHeHateMe comes away with Jrue Holiday, Jabari Smith Jr. · Kawhi So Serious? walks off with Stephen Curry, Brice Sensabaugh, 2028 R3TRADESam Presti’s Burner comes away with 2027 R1 · Shane Gillis Alexander walks off with Rui Hachimura, 2027 R2TRADEKawhi So Serious? walks off with Anfernee Simons, 2027 R3 · Sam Presti’s Burner picks up 2027 R2WIREP. Giddey brings in Sandro MamukelashviliWIREHeHateMe cuts Ryan KalkbrennerWIRESam Presti’s Burner grabs Tyrese ProctorWIREWemby and friends drops Andre DrummondWIREShep and Co. plucks Sidy CissokoWIREWemby and friends signs Bones HylandWIREP. Giddey plucks Daniss JenkinsWIRECoopa Troopas signs Jaxson HayesTHE NUMBER3: the number of times Jonathan Kuminga has been traded in this league.STATWeek 4 Hardware · High Score: P. Giddey (364.75) · Bad Beat: Shep and Co. (332.25)NEWRebuild Index: Matticus Owns the Picks, Nate Owns the TimelineNEWWeek 3 Recap: Wemby's Night Covered for the Worse TeamNEWMonday Ledger, Week 4: Every Alec Win Shrinks Lil Sweet's PickNEWMatchup Preview: Week 5 — Only One Unbeaten Has Bodies to SpareWIRELeague Desk: The Notebook, Week 4: Shep's Wembanyama Return Is All on the Shelf
State of the League

State of the League: The Summer of Trading Is Over. Now Prove It.

Bill SlimmonsOctober 8, 202616 min read
Early into Shai Gilgeous-Alexander's tenure, Oklahoma City Thunder GM Sam Presti gifted him a copy of "The Tortoise and the Hare" to ask the young guard for patience as they rebuilt the team.
Shai Gilgeous-Alexander · Shane Gillis Alexander · Photo via ESPN

Da League has officially entered the Accountability Era, and I think we're about to learn that some of the best general managers at making trades are nowhere near as good at building a championship team.

That's my biggest takeaway heading into 2026.

We've spent the entire offseason watching managers rearrange rosters, collect draft picks, chase established players, and convince themselves they've figured out something the other nine guys haven't. BigSuge has practically replaced his entire identity. Matticus has built something that looks like an Oklahoma City Thunder tribute account with an impressive collection of future firsts attached. Gooch has completely changed the construction of an 18-win team. Nate has turned established players into young prospects. And somewhere in the middle of all this, Nighthawk is sitting there with Shai Gilgeous-Alexander, Alperen Sengun, Jalen Duren, and a roster that looks increasingly interesting the longer you stare at it.

Meanwhile, we're still talking about the same three championship favorites.

Something doesn't add up.

My framework for this season is The Contender Conversion Test. You can have the best assets in Da League, you can win every offseason trade on paper, and you can build a roster that looks incredible three years from now. None of that guarantees you can turn those advantages into a championship.

The test has three questions. Can your roster win right now? Can you survive when your best players aren't carrying you? And most importantly, does your next move actually improve your chances of winning, or does it simply give you another trade to feel good about?

We've reached the point in Da League history where those questions matter more than a GM's reputation.

Two seasons gave us two different champions. The third is going to tell us which management philosophy actually lasts.

The Most Dangerous Team Might Be the One Nobody Is Discussing

I'm putting Nighthawk2334 under the microscope first because I think we've collectively gotten way too comfortable treating him as a supporting character.

Look at what he's actually done.

He finished 11-10 in 2024. He finished 11-10 again in 2025. He's been competitive without ever producing the kind of regular-season dominance that makes everyone nervous. And because of that, it's easy to file his Shane Gillis Alexander team away as the respectable middle-class franchise, the team you acknowledge before moving on to the contenders.

Except there's one problem.

He already knocked brodiedean8 out in the 2025 semifinals, the same year brodie went 19-2.

Now look at the 2026 roster.

Shai Gilgeous-Alexander. Jamal Murray. Alperen Sengun. Lauri Markkanen. Jaren Jackson. Deni Avdija. Austin Reaves. Jalen Duren. Tyler Herro.

How many teams can you confidently say have a better collection of established contributors?

Brodie can make the argument. Alec absolutely can. Gooch probably can. But we're getting into a much more interesting conversation after that.

And Nighthawk's roster has something I care about more than people realize: he doesn't need one specific player to completely change his fantasy value for the team to work.

Consider the different ways his lineup can produce. Shai gives him elite guard production. Sengun gives him a high-end center with playmaking value. Duren supplies another center option. Murray, Reaves, and Herro offer additional guard production, while Markkanen, Avdija, and Jackson give him different forward and big-man combinations.

There's a lot of flexibility there.

His most notable offseason trade sent Nikola Jović, Tre Johnson, and his 2026 and 2027 second-round picks to matticus808 for Tyler Herro and Neemias Queta. That's an interesting move because Nighthawk chose a more established offensive contributor over a younger package.

I like the logic.

The counterargument is obvious. We've had two seasons to see Nighthawk's roster management, and neither produced a dominant regular-season team. Maybe we're overrating the names, and maybe the real elite contenders still have a separation in top-end production that makes all this depth irrelevant.

Fair.

But I think we're underrating what Nighthawk's playoff history tells us about the danger of assuming the best regular-season team will automatically survive March.

And there's a second wrinkle. He doesn't control his own 2027 second-round pick, but he hasn't emptied his future first-round cupboard either. Unlike some of his competition, he has room to change direction without needing to dismantle the entire roster.

My prediction? Nighthawk finishes above his usual middle-of-the-standings neighborhood and enters March as a genuine championship threat.

I wouldn't be shocked if he ends up being the team nobody wants to face.

And if that happens, we're going to have to revisit why we spent the entire offseason obsessing over everybody else.

What will this league look like if the current path holds?

BigSuge Has Built the Ultimate Contender Conversion Test

Nobody represents the problem with evaluating offseason trades better than BigSuge.

Let's review the actual transformation because it's ridiculous.

He finished 8-13 in the inaugural season and followed that with a 6-15 record in 2025. That's two straight losing seasons, with the second one going backward in the standings.

Then he went shopping.

In February, he sent Jrue Holiday and Derik Queen to brodiedean8 in a package that brought back Anthony Davis, Jonathan Kuminga, Ryan Rollins, a 2026 third, and a 2027 third.

In June, he got Kyrie Irving and Darius Garland from lilsweet96 for Nickeil Alexander-Walker, Matas Buzelis, brodiedean8's 2026 first and second, and his own 2027 first.

The same day, he got Ja Morant and Jalen Green from Natebarrett5 for his 2026 first, 2026 second and 2027 second.

That last trade is particularly fascinating because the first-round pick eventually became AJ Dybantsa, while the second became Yaxel Lendeborg.

So BigSuge gets Morant and Green. Nate gets two actual prospects and future flexibility.

That's the kind of trade where both managers can spend the summer feeling brilliant, and only one of them might feel that way a few seasons from now.

Now BigSuge enters 2026 with Kevin Durant, Jayson Tatum, Anthony Davis, Kyrie Irving, Darius Garland, Ja Morant, LaMelo Ball, Jalen Green, and Alex Sarr in his projected starting lineup.

Read that again.

There is enough recognizable talent on this roster to make somebody forget that the franchise has never posted a winning season.

But here's where I have a problem.

We haven't seen BigSuge demonstrate that he can turn his roster into consistent fantasy victories. The stars he added this offseason certainly didn't participate in his 6-15 campaign, so using last year's record to dismiss this group would be lazy. At the same time, acquiring household names isn't proof that all their individual fantasy value will translate into a dependable lineup.

The strongest case for BigSuge is that he finally has enough established players to compete immediately. That's a perfectly reasonable argument, especially with Sarr offering an exciting younger frontcourt piece and Durant, Davis, and Tatum providing enormous name recognition and fantasy upside.

The strongest case against him is that he has concentrated his future into a group that needs to deliver now.

He no longer owns his own 2027 first, although he does hold brodiedean8's 2027 first. That's an important distinction. He has future draft value, but the team isn't positioned like a conventional rebuild.

And that's what makes his next decision so interesting.

If BigSuge is competitive early, he should resist the temptation to keep making changes simply because he can. If he struggles, he has to decide whether the roster needs an actual structural fix or whether he's just getting impatient.

I think that's the most difficult challenge for a GM who clearly enjoys changing his team.

Look. There's a version of this season where BigSuge becomes the biggest riser in league history. Going from six wins to serious contention would be an enormous achievement.

There's also a version where he discovers that assembling an impressive list of stars is considerably easier than managing one.

I'm leaning toward a winning season, but I'm stopping short of calling him a championship favorite.

He has to earn that part.

The Rookie Who Doesn't Need a Rebuild

Avery228 might be the most interesting new general manager because his team doesn't fit neatly into either of the categories we've spent the offseason discussing.

He's not doing the Matticus thing, where future draft picks and developing players are central to the entire strategy.

He's not doing the BigSuge thing, where acquiring established names is the obvious priority.

Avery's roster already looks like a team that can compete while developing a potential long-term centerpiece.

Anthony Edwards, Jalen Brunson, Franz Wagner, Pascal Siakam, Ivica Zubac, Derrick White, Josh Hart, OG Anunoby, and Cameron Boozer.

That's a serious amount of talent for somebody who hasn't managed a single regular-season game in Da League.

And the most fascinating part is how little Avery needs to change to have a competitive lineup.

The Edwards-Brunson-Wagner combination gives him an established foundation. Siakam, Zubac, White, and Hart fill out the supporting group. Boozer gives him a highly regarded younger player who doesn't have to carry the entire franchise immediately.

Avery selected Boozer first overall in our 2026 rookie draft, and the early book on him is a do-everything forward.

Obviously, he hasn't played a regular-season NBA game yet. Nobody should start handing him a dynasty MVP trophy (although somebody probably already has).

But the interesting part is the versatility.

A forward who fills every column is exactly what fantasy rewards. If that translates into meaningful fantasy production early, Avery suddenly has another valuable option without needing to remove one of his established players from the core.

There's also the matter of Zubac and Siakam, who now share Indiana's frontcourt. Zubac landed there in a February trade and missed the end of last season with a fractured rib. For Avery, that means two starters tied to the same NBA team, which is great when Indiana is rolling and a problem when it isn't.

Now, the counterargument.

Avery's roster has impressive depth, but how many of these players do you trust to produce at the level of the very best fantasy assets in Da League? Edwards and Brunson can anchor the team, but the championship favorites have stars like Nikola Jokić, Luka Dončić, and Shai Gilgeous-Alexander.

There's a legitimate ceiling question.

I still think Avery is going to outperform the expectations usually attached to a first-year GM.

He already made one June deal, sending his 2026 second-round pick to brodiedean8 for Onyeka Okongwu and Jaylon Tyson. Okongwu is still on his bench alongside Deandre Ayton, RJ Barrett, Payton Pritchard, and Andrew Nembhard.

That's meaningful roster depth.

My advice, which Avery has absolutely not requested, is to avoid making an unnecessary blockbuster before he figures out how good this group actually is.

He doesn't need a dramatic roster change to justify entering the league.

He needs to win games.

And I think he will.

Matticus Is Testing Whether You Can Rebuild and Compete Simultaneously

We've already discussed Matticus's future draft picks in the Asset Board, so I want to focus on the part of his situation that's getting less attention.

What happens if his current roster is better than a rebuilding team's roster is supposed to be?

Matticus has Jalen Williams, Chet Holmgren, Cason Wallace, Ajay Mitchell, Isaiah Hartenstein, and Jared McCain among his Oklahoma City-heavy group. He also drafted Darryn Peterson second overall in our rookie draft, Kingston Flemings seventh, and Morez Johnson ninth.

Then there's Tre Johnson, Labaron Philon, Cameron Johnson, Herbert Jones, and Aaron Nesmith.

The appeal is obvious.

He's loaded with young players, developmental possibilities, and future draft picks. He also has enough established talent that a competitive season isn't out of the question.

But this is where I think his management philosophy gets interesting.

Take the Tyrese Haliburton deal.

Matticus sent Haliburton, Walker Kessler, and brodiedean8's 2027 third to alecb5. He received Tyler Herro, Chet Holmgren, and alecb5's 2028 first.

Then he moved Herro and Neemias Queta to Nighthawk for Nikola Jović, Tre Johnson, and two Nighthawk second-round picks, one of which has already been used.

Matticus effectively took an established guard and center combination and turned it into Holmgren, additional young-player depth, and future draft opportunities.

I see the long-term logic. Holmgren fits a roster built around Jalen Williams and developing guards. The future first gives Matticus another way to improve his team without requiring every current prospect to become a star.

And remember, he also sent Trey Murphy to goochshot for Gooch's 2026 first and 2027 first. He turned the 2026 draft into actual players and still holds that 2027 first.

I think Matticus eventually runs into a problem.

At some point, you have to decide which young players you actually want to build around.

Peterson has serious offensive upside. Flemings is reportedly making a quick preseason impression with his defensive intensity, while Morez Johnson, day-to-day with a lower-leg issue, projects as a high-motor big whose defense could eventually create fantasy value.

All interesting players.

All competing for roster attention with other young players.

That's perfectly fine if the plan is to develop a contender over multiple seasons. But if Williams and Holmgren give Matticus a faster path toward winning than expected, every decision gets harder.

Does he trade some of the young depth for proven production? Does he hold everything and accept a lower short-term ceiling? Does he eventually discover that having several promising players is less useful than having a smaller group of truly dependable fantasy contributors?

Those are good problems to have.

I think Matticus could be the first GM who has to choose between protecting a terrific long-term plan and taking an unexpected shot at immediate contention.

And unlike a lot of teams, he has the actual future picks to make that choice meaningful.

Gooch Has Already Chosen His Side

Gooch doesn't have the luxury of waiting around to see what kind of team he's building.

He made the decision this summer.

After going 18-3, he sent Victor Wembanyama and three draft selections to lilsweet96 for Scottie Barnes, Paolo Banchero, Kon Knueppel, and matticus808's 2026 first.

Then he used his own 2026 first and 2027 first to acquire Trey Murphy from Matticus.

That's an extraordinary amount of roster restructuring for a team that had already established itself as one of the league's strongest regular-season performers.

And I actually understand the argument.

Gooch took one massive dynasty asset in Wembanyama and converted him into several players who could help across his lineup. Barnes and Banchero give him a pair of young forwards with significant fantasy ceilings. Knueppel offers another promising offensive contributor. Murphy supplies additional perimeter production.

Add James Harden, Donovan Mitchell, Tyrese Maxey, and Naz Reid, and there's a credible argument that Gooch has built one of the deepest offensive groups in the league.

His reported young-player context is encouraging, too. Knueppel has reportedly exceeded expectations and established himself as a major young offensive talent, while Barnes has earned recognition for his defense.

For dynasty purposes, that matters because Gooch's return for Wembanyama includes players who can contribute now and still retain substantial long-term value.

But there's another part of this roster construction I can't ignore.

Gooch's championship chances now depend on several pieces working together. With Wembanyama, he had one extraordinary asset whose individual value could anchor almost any roster configuration. Now he's asking multiple players to collectively deliver the advantage he gave away.

That can absolutely work.

It also creates more moving parts.

If the new combination produces a better starting lineup and more dependable depth, the move looks brilliant. If Gooch falls short again, he'll have to reconsider whether concentrating that much dynasty value in one player might have offered a stronger foundation.

The second-order consequence is even more interesting.

Because Matticus owns Gooch's 2027 first, Gooch has one less future tool available if he decides this roster needs another major correction.

He's built a team that should try to win now, and he has fewer easy ways to change course.

I still have Gooch among the championship contenders.

But I'm less certain that his impressive offseason guarantees he improved his chances of winning the title.

That's a distinction people keep skipping.

The Managers Who Already Know the Cost

There's a reason I haven't spent much time on Alec and Brodie yet.

We know who they are.

Brodie has an inaugural championship and the greatest regular-season record in league history. Alec has the second championship and enters this season with Luka Dončić, Jaylen Brown, Bam Adebayo, Jalen Johnson, Josh Giddey, and Tyrese Haliburton.

The reputations are earned.

But I think both managers now face a slightly different problem than the rest of the league.

They have to defend something.

Brodie still rosters Jokić, Curry, LeBron James, Cade Cunningham, Trae Young, Amen Thompson, and Stephon Castle. He also added Julius Randle and Isaiah Collier in July, sending Davion Mitchell, Moussa Diabaté, and his 2029 first and third to Gooch.

The acquisition reinforces the same aggressive approach we've seen throughout his tenure.

Brodie believes in his ability to construct a contender, and he keeps committing future assets to that mission.

You can't criticize the entire philosophy when it already produced the first championship in league history.

You can question how long he can keep doing it.

His own 2027 first belongs to BigSuge. His 2028 first belongs to Nate. His 2029 first belongs to Gooch.

That doesn't mean he's headed for a collapse. With Jokić and the rest of this lineup, he's still my preseason favorite.

But every future first he no longer controls reduces his options if the roster eventually needs a major reset.

And that's the part nobody can answer yet.

Alec has approached the same challenge differently.

His June deal with Matticus sent Chet Holmgren, Tyler Herro, and his 2028 first away in exchange for Haliburton, Walker Kessler, and brodiedean8's 2027 third.

I find that deal fascinating because it gives Alec a different type of team from the one that won the championship.

He's putting even more responsibility on established fantasy contributors while moving a younger cornerstone in Holmgren.

The upside is obvious. Luka, Haliburton, Brown, Bam, Jalen Johnson, and Giddey give him a loaded group with multiple ways to generate fantasy production.

The drawback is equally obvious. His 2027 first belongs to lilsweet96, and his 2028 first belongs to Matticus.

If this roster disappoints, rebuilding becomes more complicated.

Which brings us to the real question.

Do established champions deserve extra credit in preseason projections?

Absolutely.

They've demonstrated that they can win when the games actually matter.

But we can't give them unlimited credit. Every franchise has to earn the next season on the roster it currently controls, and being a former champion doesn't automatically make every subsequent trade a good decision.

I have Brodie and Alec at the top of my championship outlook.

I also think both are closer to a serious challenge from the rest of Da League than their reputations suggest.

The Franchise Playing a Different Game

I want to close the actual roster discussion with Natebarrett5 because Coopa Troopas might be the clearest example of a manager accepting that the championship window isn't necessarily the same thing as the calendar year.

Look at where this franchise started.

Three wins in 2024. Ten wins in 2025.

That's a substantial improvement, but it still left Nate outside the upper group.

Then he changed the future of the roster.

The February deal with 44Colt sent Kawhi Leonard and Kristaps Porziņģis away for Kyshawn George, brodiedean8's 2028 first, and Colt's 2027 and 2028 firsts.

In June, he sent Ja Morant and Jalen Green to BigSuge for BigSuge's 2026 first, 2026 second, and 2027 second.

The completed selections became AJ Dybantsa and Yaxel Lendeborg.

Nate also selected Darius Acuff fifth overall, Mikel Brown twelfth, and Christian Anderson twenty-fifth in the league rookie draft.

Add Cooper Flagg, Brandon Miller, Donovan Clingan, Dylan Harper, Cedric Coward, and Scoot Henderson, and you can see what he's trying to accomplish.

He's assembling a group that could develop together while retaining enough future first-round picks to make another major roster change.

It's an interesting strategy because he hasn't completely abandoned the present.

Joel Embiid, Zion Williamson, and Rudy Gobert are still on the roster. There are enough established pieces here that Nate could remain competitive while the younger players develop.

But I think that creates a legitimate concern.

Which version of Coopa Troopas is supposed to win?

The one built around established contributors, or the one built around Flagg, Dybantsa, Harper, and the rest of the younger group?

My biggest question isn't whether the prospects are exciting. They are.

It's whether Nate will have the patience to let those prospects develop without sacrificing the future to rescue a mediocre start.

Consider Cedric Coward, who reportedly is competing for a starting role in Memphis as of October 7. If that opportunity turns into dependable minutes, Nate has another useful young contributor. If he needs more time, the dynasty value can still exist without making an immediate difference in the standings.

The same broad principle applies to the rookie group.

Acuff enters the league after an accomplished college season. Dybantsa represents a major investment in young talent. Brown and Lendeborg provide additional developmental possibilities.

You can't assume all of them become important fantasy players immediately.

But the combination of young talent and future firsts gives Nate multiple routes toward building something much more dangerous than the team that finished last in 2024.

The counterargument is that he could have pushed harder toward immediate contention with the players he already had. Maybe selling Morant and Green means passing up an opportunity to improve this season.

I don't buy that criticism completely.

A franchise still looking for its first winning season has to be realistic about the gap between itself and the champions. Turning veteran contributors into young players and future firsts is a defensible choice.

I think Nate will be competitive enough to make the season interesting, but I wouldn't put him in the top championship tier yet.

The real test is whether he's still committed to his young core when the first difficult stretch arrives.

The Verdict: Da League Has to Stop Grading the Offseason

After looking at all of it, this is where I land.

The biggest difference between 2024, 2025, and the season we're about to begin is that we've finally accumulated enough franchise history to judge general managers by their actual decisions instead of their intentions.

In 2024, everybody was establishing an identity. Brodie won the first championship, Colt and Gooch (then playing as cadescott) built strong regular-season teams, and the rest of the league started figuring out which players and strategies mattered.

In 2025, Alec won the championship while Gooch emerged as another regular-season force. We also learned how quickly an excellent record can become irrelevant once the playoffs arrive.

Now everybody has a theory.

BigSuge thinks established talent can transform a losing franchise. Matticus thinks developing players and future picks can give him several paths toward building a contender. Gooch has prioritized a deeper collection of contributors. Nate has put substantial value into young players and future flexibility. Avery has a balanced roster that could compete immediately. Nighthawk is trying to turn a consistently competitive franchise into something more dangerous.

Meanwhile, Alec and Brodie have to keep winning if they want to preserve their places at the top of the league's historical rankings.

Those are genuinely different approaches.

And the best part is that 2026 should finally give us meaningful evidence about which ones work.

For my preseason championship outlook, Brodie remains the favorite, Alec is right behind him, and Gooch belongs in that discussion. But Nighthawk is the franchise I think has the best chance to change the established order. Avery is my pick to outperform expectations, BigSuge is the biggest test of whether recognizable talent translates into fantasy success, and Matticus might be assembling the most interesting long-term project in Da League.

My strongest prediction is that at least one of those established championship favorites will discover the rest of the league has caught up faster than expected.

The standings will eventually settle the argument.

But there's a bigger lesson here, one that I think defines the beginning of Da League's third season.

Every GM has had months to build the team they wanted. Every GM has had opportunities to trade, draft, and decide what kind of franchise they're going to run. The explanations have been made. The future has been planned. Everybody has a reason their roster should work.

Now comes the uncomfortable part.

You don't get credit for winning the trade if somebody else wins the championship.

Reported from 4 approved sources in the league record.

B

Bill Slimmons

Founder & Editor-at-Large

Big-picture takes, power rankings, legacy pieces, state of the league

What this is built on

Every claim here is grounded in real league data. The receipts:

  • SleeperCurrent standings
  • LoreFranchise lore
  • ArticleRecent related coverage
  • SleeperLeague database (Sleeper sync)

See something wrong?

Every claim here is grounded in real data. If we got one wrong, tell us.